Thursday, February 28, 2013

'Harlem Shake' poses school safety quandaries across Twin Cities


Article by: KELLY SMITH , Star Tribune
The backlash from the “Harlem Shake” Internet fad is just the latest to plague school administrators. The Harlem Shake is a hit with students, but it isn’t playing well at some schools.

As the latest flash-mob dance spreads across metro-area high schools, it has prompted suspensions and even police citations when deemed disruptive or a school safety threat. That’s leaving communities asking whether the viral video imitation is a harmless diversion or dangerous distraction.

In Eden Prairie, 16 high school students were suspended after a Harlem Shake dance in the school cafeteria that included jumping on lunchroom tables and turning one over. In Wayzata, 15 students were banned from the weight room after doing a similar dance there last week.

And at Mound Westonka High School, school leaders are still dealing with the backlash from suspending and citing six varsity hockey players before a playoff game because of a Harlem Shake rendition, with some students dancing on top of tables and chairs.

It’s a trend also seen in schools in Louisiana, Pennsylvania and Michigan, with a suburban Detroit school suspending more than 30 kids.

For school leaders, such episodes are part of the growing challenge posed by social media, forcing them to react to the latest online craze surfacing almost overnight.

“It takes moments, milliseconds [for a trend to spread],” said Don Johnson, a former principal and now head of a state group for middle and high school principals. “They happen more often and with greater intensity, which makes it hard to combat.”

Rowdy riot or fun dance?

The Harlem Shake has become an Internet phenomenon, with thousands of YouTube videos. Most feature one person dancing and, when the lyrics command to “do the Harlem Shake,” it cuts to a wild group dance.

While schools have long suffered through fashion or dance trends, Gary Amoroso, executive director of the Minnesota Association of School Administrators, said the viral videos pose even more difficulty because of how quickly they spread.

“The whole issue of social media is a challenge because it is evolving so quickly,” he said. “Schools are trying to do the best to know what’s out there and how to incorporate that positively in the schools.”

He defended local schools’ disciplinary actions, arguing that safety has to be administrators’ top priority.

Westonka investigation

In Westonka schools, district leaders said Wednesday that an outside investigation will establish what happened at the high school last Friday and whether the consequences were appropriate.

Parents and students continue to criticize the district for suspending the hockey players hours before their playoff game, arguing that officials rushed to judgment after students did the dance in the cafeteria. A cellphone video shows students dancing on tables or chairs, but no damage was reported besides a broken lunch tray.

On Monday, the hockey players and two members of a school swim team saw their two-day suspensions cut in half. The $75 citations they got from Minnetrista police were rescinded and Superintendent Kevin Borg apologized to a crowd of 250 parents and students at a school board meeting, announcing that Activities Director Dion Koltes was put on paid leave.

12 comments:

  1. The Harlem shake could be both harmless or dangerous. It depends on how aggressive they make the Harlem Shake like tipping tables or mosh pits. If they are not aggressive it is fine.

    Bryanna Bue p.7

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think that the Harlem Shake Dance has spread to other schools. I think that when they start tipping tables over, the students should have gotten suspended. The should make a rule that they can't do the Harlem Shake Dance unless they are doing it on the floor and not during school. They could do the Harlem Shake during dances.

    Ashley Otto P.2

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think these dances should not be in school. It's not a place to be during.

    Tappe

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think it's really stupid how these kids think it's funny or cool to do the Harlem shake in schools. It's getting kinda old and ridiculous. I'm starting to think they should get punished.
    David Hoang p3

    ReplyDelete
  5. I'm on both ways with this one. One way is that I think you should be able to dance to whatever you want to dance to. Teens getting suspended for doing the Harlem shake is so dumb. They are just having some fun with their sport team or a group of friends. The bad reason is like if they are dancing inappropriate then I would not liking it. I just like it when teens express what they like to do. UNLESS it is bad!

    McKenna Butler
    Hour 2

    ReplyDelete
  6. The Harlem Shake was a popular dance started 10 plus years ago. The new Harlem Shake is a misrepresentation of the dance. Real people from Harlem that were around back then are getting annoyed with the changing and misrepresentation of the dance. But with the schools I believe that students should not get in trouble If they are doing it on their own time and are not destroying school property. I think it would be easier for everyone involved just to ask the principle of their school though. If students did that then no one would have to worry about getting in trouble or be surprised.
    Brian Snyder
    P3

    ReplyDelete
  7. The Harlem Shake is harmless, it's just ridiculous how big of a deal officials of schools are making this. In Mound Westonka all the damaage there was reported was a broken lunch tray. If their lunch trays are anything like ours then the school isn't at much of a loss. All the kids are doing is having fun. Schools are squeezing any possible fun kids could have while on campus. Seriously, like were you never a teenager? Don't be those kind of people or kids will go out of their way to make job harder than it needs to be. IT IS A DANCE,not a distructive act in any way.
    Cassie Pelland
    P3

    ReplyDelete
  8. Cassie is right! The Harlem Shake is just a dance. If people would stop paying so much attention to it and not comment on every little thing that happens with it, it will eventually go away. Its not destructive and isn't going to hurt anyone who doesn't put them self in harms way. The more teachers try to stop the kids from doing it the more there going to want to do it just because you told them not to. Its a fun activity and its better than them doing something harmful to themselves or something actually destructive to your community.

    Molly Butler
    P7

    ReplyDelete
  9. I just don't understand why the students felt they needed to do this dance in the middle of a crowded lunchroom. It seems like it would be fine if it were in a safer environment. Maybe a school dance, where everybody who participated actually wanted to, instead of getting dragged into it. I don't think the dance itself is too bad (although I did not see the video), but there is a time and place for everything and people need to realize that and act appropriately.
    Abigail Johnson
    Hour 3

    ReplyDelete