The principal of Mound Westonka High School said students, including varsity hockey players, who were suspended Friday for their lunchroom rendition of popular dance craze the “Harlem Shake” went beyond just dancing, but a student disciplined for participating said Saturday that they did nothing wrong.
Senior Jack Brandstetter, 17, is among parents and students who have criticized the school’s decision not to allow him and several other players on the school’s boys’ hockey team to play in their section playoff game Friday night because of the incident.
Principal Keith Randklev defended the school’s actions Saturday, saying, “In and of itself, that type of activity would not necessarily lead to any type of school consequences. … This went beyond that.”
Brandstetter thought differently. The students, including six hockey players, were recording a school-sanctioned video of themselves performing the “Harlem Shake” in the cafeteria so that they could submit for a weekly school broadcast, he said.
As two lunchroom supervisors watched approvingly, the dancers recruited other students to join in and some of the dancers jumped onto lunch tables, Brandstetter said.
He said he did not see any tables or other school property damaged or any food thrown. After the dance, as he and others were returning their lunch trays, the school’s resident police officer and its activities director, Dion Koltes, confiscated the video camera students had been using, Brandstetter said.
He and the others then returned to their classrooms, where they heard that other police officers had been called to the school to help examine the video.
About 2 p.m., he said, he was called into the office, where Randklev, Koltes, the school police officer and an assistant principal handed him a $75 ticket they said was for “engaging in a riotlike activity and starting a mob.”
He was also told that he would be suspended for two days and would not be allowed to play in Friday night’s game.“I was totally, wrongfully accused, and not given a chance to defend myself,” he said. The other dance participants were called in one by one after him, and told the same thing, he said.
The “Harlem Shake” has become an Internet phenomenon, with thousands of YouTube videos of people dancing to the song by New York producer Baauer. While versions differ greatly, most videos consist of one person dancing by themselves and then when the lyrics command to “do the Harlem Shake” the video cuts to a group dancing crazily.A student’s 17-second cellphone video shows noisy students dancing in a cluster, some of them on tables.
Randklev wouldn’t say what exactly the students were doing that went beyond dancing but he said, “school policies were infringed upon.”
The Minnetrista police conducted its own investigation, but Randklev wouldn’t detail the results.On Friday night, the boys’ varsity team played Blake School in Minneapolis in a section quarterfinal playoff game. Blake had twice as many players on the bench as Mound Westonka. The Bears won 6-4. Parents and students expressed their anger toward Koltes at the game and on social media.
Coach Doug Runke said on Friday that the suspensions cost the team five skaters and the regular goalie. “This was not in the playbook,” he said. “We were in a tough spot.”
However, he added, that he was proud about how the rest of the team handled it. “They responded to the situation and played their hearts out.”
Brandstetter said that he and other players, along with their parents, plan to challenge the discipline. “As hockey players, we had taken away from us something we worked for our entire lives, a chance to play in a championship. It was completely unfair.”
Monday, February 25, 2013
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Stop. Before you comment how harsh this is. We gotta think about the school rules. We all have to follow them But getting a ticket and getting suspended for having fun at lunch!? Really. Come on! And the most important thing that really upsets me, these boys we're playing for the championship! Now, you took something away from those boys who can not ever get that back. This is stupid.
ReplyDeleteTappe p7
I agree with Tappe on that one, besides the harlem shake is harmless, but it really depends on the dance it self, sometimes it's people going crazy or humping the air type of dance... ok this review took a harsh turn, basically you have to see the video your self to understand it.
ReplyDeleteP:7
P. Kevin Bouphasavanh
The hockey players don't deserve the fine because its just a dance. There was no food thrown or anything like that. I think they should fight against it because it was nothing--just a dance!!
ReplyDeleteBryanna Bue P 7
I agree with Bryanna on this one because there wasn't any damage to the lunch room or any food thrown around. It's dumb to give someone a ticket for dancing. Even though it was sort of a riot like activity they shouldn't have deserved a ticket. Him not playing Fridays game would have been fair enough.
ReplyDeleteDavid Hoang p3
I believe that the students should have some sort of consequences for their behavior. But I don't think that suspending them or giving the students a ticket to pay was the answer. What they did was try to make a video copying a popular dance. Since they didn't harm anyone or any school property I don't think they should have been punished so severely. Expecially not allow several varsity hockey players not play in there section game. I bet they had been training and practicing for many years, and I know I would be very mad and disappointed if I couldn't play in my last game or advancing in the section. I think that they should have got a couple hours detention for wild behavior. I think that the school and the police took something small and turned it into a big mess.
ReplyDeleteSyd M. P2
I think that it was a bad thing that the kids started this Harlem Shake dance. They should not be dancing on the tables. It is a good thing that Jack Brandstetter got in trouble. People eat on those tables.
ReplyDeleteAshley Otto p.7
I think that the dance is pointless. I don't find it funny or entertaining, but if kids want to do it then it is ok with me. As far as this story goes, I don't agree with the suspensions. I think that the superintendent should have had more evidence before punishing these athletes.
ReplyDeleteJared Streiff p.2
I think it is wrong for them to do that dance.Their is no point in this dance,it is gross and to me it just wouldn't be my type of dance.People seem to be getting more crazy these days.I would just ignore it period!!!!!!!!!!!!!!I hate this to tell you the truth.
ReplyDeletechelsey jensen p.7.
I think they should be talked to about dancing on the tables because suspension is going to far. It's not like they were breaking any laws or doing anything extremely bad. All they were doing is making a Harlem Shake video. No food was thrown all it was, was them dancing and having fun. I don't see a big problem with that.
ReplyDeleteChenise Ehlers Period 2
I think this situation has to do alot with perspective. Us students have seen alot of the Harlem Shake, so to us, it's no big deal that those students did it in their lunchroom. The school officials at Mound Westonka more than likely hadn't seen this kind of thing before, so it's not too surprising that they acted as severely as they did. I do think that the students' punishment was too harsh, seeing that nobody was harmed and no school property was damaged.
ReplyDeleteBridget Erickson p7
The dance is just a dance. Sometimes it could get out of control, but as Lon as they kept it clean, I believe it was fine.
ReplyDeleteSo what if some kids were doing a stupid dance at lunch time? They shouldn't get suspended for it!
If anything they should have let them off with a warning.
I am really shocked about this. People have been "let off with a warning" for much, much worse.
This upsets me because these high schoolers even had permission to make the video! I don't see how a crazy wild dance will "start a riot" like the police claim. It makes no sense to suspend students for the making of a video that was approved. I heard a few days ago the principal of this school resigned because of all the publicity.
ReplyDeleteJake Wilmer p2
I understand giving them detention. That's as far as it goes! Not letting them play in their game is a punishment not only to the students but to the whole school and program. Bringing in the cops was uncalled for and unecsessary. No one was hurt and the people in charge of the lunch room didn't even have a problem with it. They thought it was funny. It wasn't even until after the incedent that the students got in trouble. It was a small thing that got blown way out of proportion
ReplyDeleteCailee Mesler 3rd period
DeleteLAST COMMENT!
ReplyDelete