(CNN) – Tamerlan Tsarnaev died early Friday, and according to the rules of Islam, he should have been buried by now. But his severely wounded body is still being held to determine a cause of death.
Tsarnaev, 26, had so many penetrating wounds when he arrived at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center early Friday that doctors could not tell which ones had killed him. He'd engaged in a ferocious battle with police in which more than 200 rounds of gunfire was exchanged. He and his brother Dzhokhar, 19, also allegedly hurled improvised explosive devices and handmade grenades at officers.
There are questions about when, where and how Tamerlan Tsarnaev will be buried. And there's a bigger question: whether any Muslim entity will be willing to deliver last rites.
Many Muslim community leaders have sought to distance themselves from the Tsarnaevs in light of reports that Tamerlan Tsarnaev might have been influenced by radical Islam. Fearing retaliation, Muslim leaders have strongly condemned the bombings and made it clear that Islam does not condone violence. At least one Boston cleric said he would refuse to perform funeral rites for a man accused of committing so much violence. The Quran, said Imam Talal Eid, says that anyone who has killed another human being is going to hell.
Eid, who is imam at the Boston Islamic Institute, said he had never met the Tsarnaev brothers but questioned media accounts that Tamerlan Tsarnaev had become a devout Muslim. "A person who is devoted does not kill innocent people," Eid said.
Yusufi Vali, executive director of the Islamic Society of Boston Cultural Center, the largest mosque in the Boston area, also rejected the Tsarnaev brothers. "I don't care who or what these criminals claim to be, but I can never recognize these criminals as part of my city or my faith community," he said. "All of us Bostonians want these criminals to be brought to justice immediately. I am infuriated at the criminals of these bombings for trying to rip our city apart. We will remain united and not let them change who we are as Bostonians."
The Tsarnaev brothers occasionally attended prayer services at the Islamic Society of Boston Cambridge Masjid, a small mosque near their apartment in Cambridge, Massachusetts. "In their visits, they never exhibited any violent sentiments or behavior," said a statement from the masjid. "Otherwise they would have been immediately reported to the FBI. After we learned of their identities, we encouraged anyone who knew them in our congregation to immediately report to law enforcement, which has taken place."
I think that if law enforcement was going to shoot someone to apprehend someone then they shouldn't shoot them so many time. I also think that if they didn't show any signs of agression in a church or monestary then they might not be the suspects. As far as religion goes just because that the one of them that got shot is not buried yet mabe that's a good thing. Let the terrorists know that we are not going to take anything from them.
ReplyDeleteMatthew Hodek
Per. 3
I think that they shouldn't be buried at all. All they did was kill innocent people for no apparent reason. So it'd be a waste of time to bury some murderers.
ReplyDeleteDavid Hoang Per3
That's an interesting moral question. What burial honors should a terrorist receive? On one hand, they killed many people, but on the other, they are still a human being. I don't blame Islamic leaders for not wanting to give him his last rites. Mainstream Muslims want to distance themselves from radical Islam just as much as mainstream Christians want to distance themselves from hate groups like the Westboro Baptist Church.
ReplyDeleteI don't believe that terrorist should of got a church funeral. He was killing a lot of people for no reason. The terrorist was not following his church's beliefs.
ReplyDeleteAshley Otto p2
I believe that yes, what he did was terrible. And I fully understand why people who were involved in the bombing wouldn't want this terrorist to have his final rights. But as Andrew said he is still a human being. Therefore he should be buried correctly. Not with any ceremony necessarily but even people on death row are given a proper burial. No doubt that only a terrible man would do anything like this, yet if we do not allow a proper burial we are lowering ourselves and our morals. He also still has family living and if I had been one of the people who was involved or lost a loved one from the bombing, I would sympathize with them. Ultimately the matter should be in the hands of his living relatives because they lost someone because of this as well. Another reason we should leave it up to his loved ones is so that we wouldn't have to worry about it. Why should we be wasting time and thoughts about such a disgusting person?
ReplyDeleteCailee Mesler p3
I think that no matter what a person has done in their past, even if it is as bad as something like this, should determine whether or not they get buried. Everyone is a person and deserves to be properly buried in my opinion. Although I do not think that they should receive some luxuries such as a funeral or a ceremony.
ReplyDeleteJared Streiff p2
I think that these men who did the terrorize at Boston marathon were severely damaged by something. They could have just been crazy, but why kill so many innocent people? For revenge? On what? It's kind of upsetting that this man maybe not get a proper burial. He is human, but did Osama Bin Laden get a proper burial? He was thrown into the ocean! I know that he killed way more people than these two men, but if people wanted them to have a proper burial we should give every criminal a burial that's "proper." It's just upsetting that humans are so malevolent towards each other.
ReplyDeleteSamantha H. period 7
Let me start by saying that what they did was horrible. It was an act of terror and three people died (including an eight year old boy.) But how is it that much different than serial killers? Both terrorists and serial killers end innocent lives and both use violent methods to end such lives. Yet, the serial killers on death row (as Cailee pointed out) get proper burials. Any human being deserves something as simple as that. We should not take responsibility for it, however. I feel that it should be a matter for his family to decide. If you had died, would it make sense for someone other than your family to make decisions about your burial? (Besides, when it comes to being cast into the ocean? That's called 'burial at sea' and many cultures have used it as a respectable way to honor the dead.)
ReplyDeleteMorgan A-B, Period 2
LAST COMMENT!
ReplyDelete